There are a few factors to consider when purchasing softball mitts. The size of the mitt, the webbing, and the padding are important things to look at when making your decision. Another thing to keep in mind is what level of softball you will be playing. There are different types of mitts for different levels of play.
We created this list of the best softball mitts with ratings and reviews to help you make an informed decision when purchasing your next pair of mitts. We hope that this list will help you find the perfect pair of mitts for your needs.
10 Best Softball Mitts | June 2023 (Reviewed & Ranked)
Last updated on June 12, 2023
10 minutes
OUR TOP PICKS
A Few Of Our Ranking Metrics:
Check below for our tips on purchasing the best Softball Mitts:
View Buying Guide
The 10 best Softball Mitts
Top #1
Rawlings | Sure Catch Softball Glove Series | Youth | Multiple Styles
94%
Customer
Satisfaction
100%
Overall
Score
95%
Product
Quality
View on Amazon
WHAT WE LIKE:
This glove is designed to make plays all over the field, and it's perfect for young athletes just starting to learn the game. It has a durable, lightweight design that includes an all-leather shell and padded finger linings, and it features Rawlings Sure-Catch technology so players can quickly and easily close the baseball glove as soon as they put it on for the first time.
Pros & Cons From Reviewers:
It arrived quickly.
The gloves are durable and fit well.
It is well made and fit the little girls hands well.
Read More Reviews
Top #2
Easton | Fundamental Fastpitch Softball Glove | Multiple Styles
92%
Customer
Satisfaction
95%
Overall
Score
90%
Product
Quality
View on Amazon
WHAT WE LIKE:
The sellers product description mentions that the mitts have specific patterns and sizes for female hands, as well as a quantum closure system that allows them to be adjusted for a secure fit. Additionally, the cowhide leather is oil-tanned and super soft, making it perfect for gripping and controlling balls. The left "hand orientation" selection offers the option of having the mitts on your right hand when you throw with your left hand, while the right "hand orientation" selection offers the option of having them on your left hand when you throw with your right hand.
Pros & Cons From Reviewers:
The glove is good.
They break in well, making them more comfortable to wear.
It is good for the look of it.
Read More Reviews
Top #3
Rawlings | RSB Slowpitch Softball Glove Series | Multiple Styles
96%
Customer
Satisfaction
95%
Overall
Score
90%
Product
Quality
View on Amazon
WHAT WE LIKE:
This glove is designed for adult slowpitch softball players and is made of durable all-leather shell and padded finger linings. It has a custom fit for every athlete and features a Neo-Flex back and velcro strap to ensure a comfortable fit.
Pros & Cons From Reviewers:
The glove is comfortable.
The gloves are good for softball.
The hand is an average size for an adult.
Read More Reviews
Top #4
Mizuno Premier Slowpitch Softball Glove Series
95%
Customer
Satisfaction
93%
Overall
Score
88%
Product
Quality
View on Amazon
WHAT WE LIKE:
The imported butter soft palm liner is designed to increase durability, feel, and comfort. The full grain leather palm/pigskin back is designed for great durability. The power lock wrist strap ensures a secure fit.
Pros & Cons From Reviewers:
It smells good.
The gloves fit well and are of high quality.
The glove is big enough to grow into.
Read More Reviews
Top #5
Rawlings | Liberty Advanced Fastpitch Softball Glove Series | Multiple Styles
91%
Customer
Satisfaction
91%
Overall
Score
87%
Product
Quality
View on Amazon
WHAT WE LIKE:
The best features of this product are the full-grain leather, the pull-strap closures, and the quick break-in.
Pros & Cons From Reviewers:
The Rawlings Liberty Advanced first base mitt is arguably one of the best fast pitch gloves on the market for competitive players.
The gloves are made well and fit well.
Good protection against balls in the dirt being thrown at high speed from shortstop.
Read More Reviews
Top #6
Mizuno Prospect Select Fastpitch Softball Glove Series | Full Grain Leather | Female Specific Patterns | ButterSoft Palm Liner
87%
Customer
Satisfaction
91%
Overall
Score
88%
Product
Quality
View on Amazon
WHAT WE LIKE:
The best features of these softball mitts are the full grain leather shell, youth sizes, and parashock palm pad.
Pros & Cons From Reviewers:
The glove is soft and fits well.
It was able to break it in relatively quickly.
The price is good.
Read More Reviews
Top #7
WILSON 2022 Flash Fastpitch Softball Glove Series
95%
Customer
Satisfaction
91%
Overall
Score
86%
Product
Quality
View on Amazon
WHAT WE LIKE:
The best features of these softball mitts are that they are split and have pro lace.
Pros & Cons From Reviewers:
The material is amazing and the break in is quick and easy.
The glove makes a difference for children who are learning to catch.
The glove pocket helps the ball better as well.
Read More Reviews
Top #8
WILSON 2022 A550 Siren Fastpitch Softball Glove Series
96%
Customer
Satisfaction
91%
Overall
Score
87%
Product
Quality
View on Amazon
WHAT WE LIKE:
The best features of these softball mitts are the quick fit wrist and the 12-inch length.
Pros & Cons From Reviewers:
It is almost professional in feel.
The learning experience can be helpful for teens who want to play baseball.
The daughter loves it.
Read More Reviews
Top #9
Franklin Sports Fastpitch Pro Series Softball Gloves Right or Left Hand Throw Adult and Youth Sizes 11in, 11.5in, 12in, 12.5in and 13in Size Mitts
83%
Customer
Satisfaction
91%
Overall
Score
88%
Product
Quality
View on Amazon
WHAT WE LIKE:
The best features of this product are the lightweight mesh design, the adjustable wrist closure, and the soft pocket.
Pros & Cons From Reviewers:
It is good for children who are not as serious about softball as their parents.
It is good if the person is left-handed.
Read More Reviews
Top #10
WILSON 2021 A360 Adult Slowpitch Softball Glove
96%
Customer
Satisfaction
90%
Overall
Score
86%
Product
Quality
View on Amazon
WHAT WE LIKE:
The best features of these softball mitts are the closed V-shaped web, carbonlite shell, and velcro design for easy in-game adjustments.
Pros & Cons From Reviewers:
It is good quality.
Read More Reviews
Softball Mitts Buying Guide : What You Need To Know
*Our top pick for the best Softball Mitts
Attributes Of High Quality Softball Mitts
- The mitt should be made of high quality, durable leather.
- It should have a deep pocket to help field the ball.
- The webbing between the thumb and first finger should be tight, so that balls don't pop out.
How To Choose The Best Softball Mitts
When it comes to playing softball, having the right equipment is essential to performing your best on the field. One of the most important pieces of equipment for any softball player is a good quality glove, and this is especially true for infielders. Infielder's gloves are designed specifically for the rigors of playing in the infield, and they need to be both durable and comfortable in order to help you perform your best. With so many different gloves on the market, it can be tough to know which one is right for you. Here are a few tips to help you choose the best softball mitts for your needs.
1. Consider the size of the glove. Infielder's gloves come in a variety of sizes, so it's important to choose one that's comfortable for you to wear. If the glove is too big, it will be difficult to control, and if it's too small, it won't offer enough protection. Try on a few different gloves before making your final decision to make sure you've found the perfect fit.
2. Look for a well-padded glove. Playing softball often results in hard-hit balls, so it's important to have a glove that can protect your hand from impact. Look for a glove with plenty of padding in the palm and around the fingers to cushion your hand against those hard-hit balls.
3. Make sure the glove is well-constructed. A good quality glove will be made from high-quality materials that are built to last. Avoid cheaper gloves that are made from lower-quality materials, as they won't stand up to regular use and will likely fall apart quickly. Pay attention to the stitching on the glove as well; higher-quality gloves will have stronger stitching that won't come undone easily.
4. Choose a style that suits your needs. Infielder's gloves come in a variety of styles, so it's important to choose one that suits your specific needs. If you're looking for extra protection from hard-hit balls, look for a thicker glove with more padding. If you prefer a lighter weight glove that doesn't sacrifice dexterity, look for one made from thinner materials.
5. Consider your budget. Infielder's gloves range in price from around $20 to $200 or more, so it's important to consider your budget when making your purchase. If you're just starting out, you may want to opt for a cheaper model until you get a feel for what you need in a glove. However, if you're an experienced player who wants top-of-the-line performance, you'll need to be willing to spend more money on a higher-end model.
By following these tips, you should be able to find the perfect softball mitts for your needs and budget
What To Avoid When Looking For The Best Softball Mitts
When choosing the best softball mitt, there are a few key things to avoid in order to ensure you're getting the most bang for your buck. First and foremost, avoid mitts with too much padding. While padding is important in a softball mitt, too much of it can make the mitt bulky and difficult to control. Secondly, avoid mitts with excessively deep pockets. Deep pockets may seem like they would be ideal for scooping up softballs, but they can actually be more difficult to control than shallower pockets. Finally, avoid mitts with overly stiff leather. Stiff leather mitts are less likely to break in and may be uncomfortable to use. When shopping for a softball mitt, keep these things in mind and you'll be sure to find the perfect one for you!